Ugly. Truly ugly. I think I expected a story of redemption, of humanity, of virtue shining through corruption and initiative shining through social injustice. Maybe a tale of personal growth on behalf of the narrator (whom the reader knows already from the back cover is a murderer), but even that aspect of it all is questionable. It was an ugly story depicting an ugly – though intelligent – character in ugly circumstances. If it truly provides an honest depiction of Indian society, then it is an ugly, ugly set of power relations and values indeed, a case for despair and for helpless sympathy. Have I used the word ugly too many times? Unfortunately it is the only word that comes to mind.
About six years ago – around the time I decided that I would not do my big overseas working holiday prior to establishing a career and starting a family, but instead take my established family and career overseas with me when I was older – I came up with a reading plan to support my intentions of travelling to many interesting places. I decided that I would not visit a foreign country without reading at least one well-informed book set in that country. Preferably I would read this before actually arriving there. Preferably I would read two – one non-fiction book about the country’s history, and the other a well-researched novel written by someone who had actually spent some time living in that country. This would address a few problems: my poor knowledge of history and geography; my tendency to choose fiction over non-fiction; and the lengthy period of time which was likely to pass prior to my actually getting overseas again.
I almost managed this task on our trip to France. I read all of “A Tale of Two Cities” by Dickens, and half of “The French Revolution” by Christopher Hibbert, most of that whilst failing to sleep on a plane. It was a really good thing to do, though I’m glad I didn’t get to the really gory bits of “The French Revolution” before sleeping in old Paris. Even the gite in Gourec, Britanny, I now recognise, was absolutely seething with something or somebody long past.
So back to our novel based in India: “The White Tiger” was well-researched and written by somebody who had actually spent a good deal of time living there, as was Arundhati Roy’s “The God of Small Things”. I enjoyed “The God of Small Things”, don’t really recall what it was about but it must have contained more humanity, virtue and redemption of one kind or another because I was still interested in visiting India after reading it. “The White Tiger” makes me quite comfortable with the fact that I am not likely to visit India for a very long time.
